I have long thought that there should be more sites like GR,
evaluating teachers from a thousand points of view, etc. Even without
commenting, "selection" itself, choosing whom to list, will
create a subtle evaluation criterion, with a thousand choosers
determining an overall evaluation. One thing that will skew this
though, is the mechanistic nature of some of the "choosing."
I speak here of copying and pasting. In the course of updating links,
trying to find replacement sites for the inevitable migrations, from wannabes who could
never get it together to real teachers who just move or update their
sites for whatever reason, i have encountered sites that do nothing but
list teachers, supplementing their lists with categories clearly taken
from my listings, eg (O), (S) etc, or snippets of comments, done in
such a mishmash way as to be totally worthless. This is done without
acknowledgement, and apparently for whatever ad revenue (shurely
meagre!) they can scrounge from visitors to their essentially
worthless presentations (sans context, links, alphabetical order or
even sometimes sense) .
There ARE exceptions, one being one of the first i found, using just
my Buddhist pages as a RELEVANT adjunct to Buddhist info they were
already presenting.
So here they are:
1. Supermercado
Espiritual, a blog nominally in Spanish, whose only Spanish
components are Headings, eg Sistema
de Creencias (followed by a long pilfered list in English) and 1500
Gurús del Gurugú de la A a la Z (followed by my complete listings as
of 2007).
2. GanaPatioCCult.com/, Indian site, the C stands for Cargo. They purport to
offer info on all things relating to Hinduism, festooned with ads for
American hotels. The "Hindu Guru" section is 100% derived
from GR, being a directory organised by my categories, each category
having a page listing however
many they bothered to choose (with no obvious criteria, eg only two in
the Humour page and nine on the New Age page. Each individual guru's
"page" consists of name, rating if applicable, aka, though
often missing or truncated, and the first fifty or so characters of my
description, even of the major gurus of actual interest to the wider
Indian public, such as Sri Sri Ravi Shankar, with no links leading
anywhere save the ad links. Can this be of any value even to them?
Will anyone click on their ads or read the page for more than a
second? Totally worthless, i'd say.
3. YouAreThat.com
is more general-market-oriented but offers exactly the same material
(down to the same two Humour wallahs -- in fact even the same page
numbering system) as Ganapatioccult above. As YouAreThat was the first
to be noticed, back in Mar 2006, one suspects that in fact
Ganapatioccult has ripped off THEIR ripoff of GR rather than GR
directly. Ha ha!
Back when i found them, i wrote about the discovery in GRF:
Most of the entries are
abbreviated and somewhat mishmashed but aside from
misspellings, eg "Advaitva," there is no original
text. But they claim copyright ("Copyright ©2004 You Are
That.com. All rights reserved") via another apparent
shell outfit with little contact info. They do not link to me
nor acknowledge my original work in any way except
incidentally when, in an entry, they have copied whole a link
to another page in my site.
It is a commercial site, with lots of Google ads and links to
other directory- type sites they run, like http://www.findillinoislawyeronline.com/,
etc.
The "host company" is CGS Infotech, with contact
addresses in Delaware -- i never noticed before there is an
"aware" in Delaware -- and Mumbai, formerly known as
Bombay. Contacting them via net is only possible using a form
for applicants for their "services," which include
webhosting and search engine placement (neat little trick,
their hundreds of nominally independent "sites"
point to your site and make it look more "popular"
according to the Google algorithm).
Given the paucity of information about them and the short list
of contacts, it looks like a shell operation with just a
couple of principals, trying to develop a web angle, of which
youarethat.com is a tiny, botched fragment. Actually this site
looks more like a labour of love than
findillinoislawyeronline.com, say.
|
4. Secretia Another Spanish
bloggy site which turns out, like
Ganapatioccult above, to be ripping the ripper; in this case, Supermercado
Espiritual above. It has far more content but everything in the
Supermercado page is here, dated four months later. Also gone much
further in that there are approx 130 versions of this material in
Secretia, in pages with different languages and apparent themes, eg
Numerology, Reiki, times Hungarian, Thai, etc. The Sistema
de Creencias section actually has translations into the other
languages, save the Spanish title, but the 1500
Gurús del Gurugú de la A a la Z (followed by my complete listings as
of 2007) is unchanged. This notwithstanding that there appears to be
lots of other "original" -- copied from who knows where --
and relevant (thematic) material in, say, Bulgarian, on, say, alchemy,
also on the page. Bizarre!
5. SanchezDrago.com
Spanish forum, with entire contents of Supermercado page above posted
by ostensible author, "Sé
y Haz."
6. UrbanDharma.org
The first, the "original" and most thematically coherent and
respectful copycat, they took the entire contents of my three
Buddhist-themed pages, with bumpf and then-functioning links (in 2003)
as a kind of real Buddhist directory. They did have the grace to
acknowledge where they got the material. Just noticed now: the second
column of the Tibetans page is missing, they only go up to Lopon. Oh
well, probably no one ever missed it.
7. Your Site Could Be
Here!
|